Proposal to deduct pay during partial strikes
Would let employers deduct part of an employee’s pay during a partial strike, after giving written notice.
Employment Relations (Pay Deductions for Partial Strikes) Amendment Bill
Proposed by Hon Brooke van Velden · Introduced 9 Dec 2024
Party at introduction: ACT New Zealand
What it would change
Pay deductions for partial strikes
Employers responding to a partial strike could accept it, or suspend or lock out employees. Suspended striking employees were not entitled to pay during the suspension. Employers would be able to deduct pay from employees taking part in a partial strike without suspending or locking them out. The deduction would not be allowed for safety or health strikes, certain piece-work strikes, or strikes involving only specified overtime or call-out refusals.
Employment Relations Act 2000 — Section 12 Specified pay deductions must cease on commencement Version: 26 Nov 2024
Employment Relations Act 2000 — Section 87 Suspension of striking employees Version: 26 Nov 2024
Employment Relations (Pay Deductions for Partial Strikes) Amendment Bill — Clause 95A Employer may make specified pay deductions in relation to partial strike Version: 9 Dec 2024
Employment Relations (Pay Deductions for Partial Strikes) Amendment Bill — Explanatory note Version: 9 Dec 2024
Two ways to calculate the deduction
The supplied earlier text does not set out a current 10% option for partial-strike deductions. It records that earlier specified deductions had to cease when the 2018 changes began. Employers would calculate the deduction from the work the employee would not perform, as a percentage of usual working hours, or choose a flat 10% deduction for the partial-strike pay period. Group calculations would be limited to employees doing the same or similar work.
Employment Relations Act 2000 — Section 12 Specified pay deductions must cease on commencement Version: 26 Nov 2024
Employment Relations (Pay Deductions for Partial Strikes) Amendment Bill — Clause 95C Calculation of specified pay deduction Version: 9 Dec 2024
Employment Relations (Pay Deductions for Partial Strikes) Amendment Bill — Explanatory note Version: 9 Dec 2024
Notice before deductions
The supplied earlier text says earlier specified deductions applied before the 2018 changes, but does not provide the earlier notice rule for those deductions. An employer would have to give written notice as soon as reasonably practicable, before the first deduction or the end of the first relevant pay period. The notice would identify the pay period, but need not state the deduction amount.
Employment Relations Act 2000 — Section 12 Specified pay deductions must cease on commencement Version: 26 Nov 2024
Employment Relations (Pay Deductions for Partial Strikes) Amendment Bill — Clause 95B Notice of specified pay deduction Version: 9 Dec 2024
Employment Relations (Pay Deductions for Partial Strikes) Amendment Bill — Explanatory note Version: 9 Dec 2024
Recovering overpaid wages
Employers could recover overpaid wages for unauthorised absences, strikes, lockouts, or suspensions, subject to notice and other conditions. Partial strikes were not listed in the recoverable period. If an employer were entitled to make a partial-strike deduction but paid usual wages, the employer could recover the overpayment. Notice would be due no later than 10 working days after the pay day and would have to state the calculation method used.
Wages Protection Act 1983 — Section 4 No deductions from wages except in accordance with Act Version: 1 Jul 2022
Wages Protection Act 1983 — Section 6 Employer may recover overpayments in certain circumstances Version: 1 Jul 2022
Employment Relations (Pay Deductions for Partial Strikes) Amendment Bill — Clause 11 Section 6 amended (Employer may recover overpayments in certain circumstances) Version: 9 Dec 2024
Employment Relations (Pay Deductions for Partial Strikes) Amendment Bill — Explanatory note Version: 9 Dec 2024
Education-service deductions
Education-service employers could not lock out or suspend striking employees during collective-agreement negotiations unless the Public Service Commissioner directed otherwise. The Commissioner’s listed powers included lockouts and suspensions. An education-service employer would not be able to make a specified partial-strike deduction unless the Public Service Commissioner directed it. The Commissioner would have power to make or direct such a deduction for State school board employees.
Education and Training Act 2020 — Section 586 Negotiation of conditions of employment Version: 1 Oct 2024
Education and Training Act 2020 — Section 587 Public Service Commissioner's powers when collective agreements are negotiated Version: 1 Oct 2024
Employment Relations (Pay Deductions for Partial Strikes) Amendment Bill — Clause 13 Section 586 amended (Negotiation of conditions of employment) Version: 9 Dec 2024
Employment Relations (Pay Deductions for Partial Strikes) Amendment Bill — Clause 14 Section 587 amended (Public Service Commissioner’s powers when collective agreements are… Version: 9 Dec 2024
Employment Relations (Pay Deductions for Partial Strikes) Amendment Bill — Explanatory note Version: 9 Dec 2024
Who's affected
Employers, employees and unions involved in partial strikes, plus education-service employers and the Public Service Commissioner, would be affected.
When
This is a proposal still at the just-introduced stage; if passed, it would start the day after it receives assent, and would not apply to earlier partial-strike periods.
Background
The government says the Bill would encourage parties in industrial action to reach agreement sooner by giving employers a specific response to partial strikes.