Most Fair Trading breaches would face civil penalties
Most Fair Trading breaches would move to civil penalties, while online service providers would receive limited protection for disrupting suspected scams in good faith.
Fair Trading Amendment Bill
Proposed by Hon Cameron Brewer · Introduced 13 May 2026
Party at introduction: National
What it would change
Criminal offences replaced by civil penalties
Many breaches of Parts 1 to 4 of the Fair Trading Act were criminal offences, with maximum fines of $200,000 for individuals and $600,000 for companies. The listed tier 1 and tier 2 breaches would generally be civil liability provisions. The Commerce Commission could seek a civil penalty, while criminal offences would remain for provisions not moved into this regime, including section 9.
Fair Trading Act 1986 — Section 40 Contraventions of provisions of Parts 1 to 4A an offence Version: 1 Jul 2026
Fair Trading Act 1986 — Section 40A Additional penalty for contravention of section 24 involving commercial gain Version: 1 Jul 2026
Fair Trading Amendment Bill — Clause 41B What are civil liability provisions Version: 25 Sept 2026
Fair Trading Amendment Bill — Clause 41A Overview of civil liability Version: 25 Sept 2026
Fair Trading Amendment Bill — Clause 41F When High Court may make pecuniary penalty orders Version: 25 Sept 2026
Civil proceedings and compensation
Courts and the Disputes Tribunal could already order refunds, repairs, payments for loss, or other remedies for qualifying conduct, generally within three years of discovering the loss. A court or the Disputes Tribunal would be able to order whole or partial compensation when a Fair Trading Act breach causes, or is likely to cause, loss or damage. Civil cases would use the usual civil evidence rules and standard of proof.
Fair Trading Act 1986 — Section 43 Other orders Version: 1 Jul 2026
Fair Trading Act 1986 — Section 43A Application for order under section 43 Version: 1 Jul 2026
Fair Trading Amendment Bill — Clause 41C When High Court may make declarations of contravention Version: 25 Sept 2026
Fair Trading Amendment Bill — Clause 41J When court or Disputes Tribunal may make compensatory orders Version: 25 Sept 2026
Fair Trading Amendment Bill — Clause 41K Terms of compensatory orders Version: 25 Sept 2026
Fair Trading Amendment Bill — Clause 43N Rules of civil procedure and civil standard of proof apply to civil liability Version: 25 Sept 2026
Protection for scam disruption
Telecommunications providers, website hosts, digital platforms, and domain-name registrars would have a defence if they disrupt suspected scams proportionately and in good faith, begin within 28 days, and promptly reverse action when reasonably practicable after grounds disappear.
Fair Trading Amendment Bill — Clause 33 New section 48U inserted (Defence against civil liability for action taken by online… Version: 25 Sept 2026
Fair Trading Amendment Bill — Clause 48U Defence against civil liability for action taken by online service providers to disrupt… Version: 25 Sept 2026
Fair Trading Amendment Bill — Clause 47 Section 23 amended (Liability of online content host for content posted by user) Version: 25 Sept 2026
Who's affected
Businesses, consumers, the Commerce Commission, courts, the Disputes Tribunal, and online service providers would be affected.
When
This is a proposal still being examined or debated in Parliament; it would apply from a date not yet confirmed if passed.
Background
The committee says the bill would update Fair Trading Act enforcement for changing business practices and digital markets, strengthen deterrence, and support scam disruption.